Aug 272013

That great idea for the better mousetrap might have gone to thousands of people, but few start and fewer finish.

I hear a whole lot of reasons why someone won’t put an idea or piece of work out there. Don’t have time, can’t start, can’t finish, can’t handle criticism in case the work stinks, it’s not perfect.

But one objection I’m hearing a lot these days is that someone might steal your idea or your work.

That’s enough to paralyze just about anybody, and if you have a thing about conspiracies you’re gonna drop down into that rabbit hole.

I like how the Nobel Prize committee awards groundbreaking work in a number of disciplines. Often two scientists will come up with duplicate or similar work even though they may have never heard of one another, never met, never worked together. If the work is deemed worthy of a Nobel, both will receive the award for separate but similar work.

H’mm. Maybe brilliant ideas are not so exclusive after all.

Noted writer and social commentator Mark Twain put it this way: There are no original ideas. Never really have been. It’s impossible, he said. All the same old ideas go into a kaleidoscope, given a good shake and whatever you see is the the recycled ideas arranged in a new way.

I have a real goofball theory, and I could be totally full of it. I’ll admit it’s happened before and will probably happen again in my life.

But here’s the theory: If something is meant to get done, it’ll get done.

Brilliance evolves, but not without starting

Because of that, a brilliant idea will go out to a random handful of people. Maybe a few hundred or a few thousand. But it’s dispensed to quite a few people with the thought that someone, somewhere will make it come alive. And eventually it will.

I have no numbers to back this up, but the rest is just a winnowing process:

  • I expect most of these people will never know they have this wonderful idea.
  • From there, others will know they have an idea but have no idea what to do with it.
  • Then you’ll have some who know what to do with it, but can’t formulate a plan to save their lives.
  • Of those who can, many will dither over the plan because it’s a fine substitute for starting. Many people don’t have the guts to start; already some excuses will kick in. Don’t have the time, don’t have the money, no one will buy it, all that good stuff.

OK, now we’re down to a small minority. Again, no real numbers but we’re getting to a select few here.

  • Of the starters, the majority will buckle under the resistance that is guaranteed to come up. They’ll go off the road, give up at the first roadblock, decide it’s safer to go golfing instead.

But not everyone can stand this kind of resistance. It knocks out the best of ’em. To even get this far is huge. Starters are definitely in the vast minority.

  • As the course continues and resistance increases, this whittles down the field considerably. Many will drop out and many will slow down. But notice something here. You’ll find fewer excuses per capita. Those who start can pat themselves on the back; at least they took some sort of action even though the dedication might flag.

Like they used to say with the Arizona state lottery, you can’t win if you don’t play.


Few chosen from among the many

By then, the idea is held by just a chosen few. These are the dedicated ones, who approach the whole idea with a single eye, and pay whatever price to bring this thing into fruition.

What about those who didn’t even get in the game?

Those are the ones who swear someone stole their idea.

Among the chosen few, the rest is a sprint. Several may finish, but whoever wins that race — either by getting there first or just building that mousetrap a whole lot better — gets to write the history.

That’s where the Wright Brothers are separated from the Langleys, the Edisons from all the other wannabe light-bulb makers, the Robert Pearys from the Frederick Cooks. The Americans from the Russkies in the race to the moon. These are the ones who finished, got there first or did it better. Or more likely, all of the above.

But they all started, which must be done before winning.

You don’t hear the Langleys, the Cooks and the Russians whining about how someone stole their idea, do you? Ask any of them honestly and they’ll tell you they put up the good fight but other guy won it fair and square. At that level you won’t hear whining.

They all started, which is the biggest prerequisite to finishing.

It’s those who are stuck at the bottom, those who won’t act on the idea, those who won’t start that’ll snivel that no one gave them a chance.

For years I didn’tdo anything with my gifts. I complained a lot, too. But once I made my mind to start something I didn’t whine near as much. Every time I bashed through a barrier, I just didn’t have time to whine. My level of commitment increases with each hurdle cleared. If I actually make it to the final sprint, sniveling is just not an option. Finishing and doing a killer job are.

Even if someone decides to lift an idea after someone else wins, more than likely it will be of inferior quality. Shoot, there are websites out there that will show you how to make something that mimics the In & Out burger. Will it be as good? Probably not.

On the other hand, if someone picks up a finished idea and does it better, puts it at a whole new level, then more power to him. He’s perfected the idea and gets noted for his achievement. It’s like the old joke that someone had to invent the toilet seat, but someone else improved it by cutting a hole in it.

The guy who designed all the hot new aircraft you see these days belongs in the winner’s circle, but it doesn’t diminish what the Wright Brothers achieved.

No guts, no glory.

Stolen ideas? Puh-leeeze. No one can lay claim to an idea until he does something with it.

If the idea is worth a lick, someone is going to finish it. It’s like on the job where the boss man says if you can’t dig a post hole straight, he’ll find someone who can. Same principle.

Many are called, few are chosen.

# # #

Jun 292012

If Edison laid down on the job, the light bulb would still have been invented ... by someone else.

“If (these guys) didn’t do their work, it still would have been accomplished. Only Joe Smoe might have invented the light bulb, Joe Sixpack might have created the airplane, and Joe Lunchmeat might have written The Godfather.”

* * *

“They stole my idea!”

I’m sure you’ve heard that one, and probably enough times to know what it actually means.

Every time something brilliant comes down the pike, you know someone will say he had the idea first and someone stole it. Right out from under him, just snatched it right from his brain or something. Or he didn’t have the a) chance, b) money or c) backing to pull it off.

Try d): Didn’t have the vision or the motivation or the ‘nads necessary to make it work.

Who is the person who would utter such a lament?

I can guarantee you, this is the person who doesn’t get ideas very often, and when he does he’s clueless what to do with it.

One of the hard truths about the creative’s life is that ideas are cheap.


This bears repeating: Ideas are cheap.

And if you’re creative, you learn these ideas are like buses. Another will be along directly. A true creative never has a shortage of ideas; more often than not he’ll have more of them than he has time to execute them. He has to decide, which ones are worth the effort?

It’s like fishing. Some ideas are keepers. Others may put up more of a fight than you are able and/or willing to handle. And some are not developed enough and should be thrown back. Maybe you’ll catch it later, or maybe someone else will. It does not matter.

But that is indeed the way things are. Ideas are not exclusive. Among minds, they’re public domain. If you don’t pick it up and do something with it, someone else will.

Things will get done whether you decide to show up for work or not. That’s how things work in the great scheme of things. While you’re out playing with the squirrels your brilliant idea will be given to someone else, and it’ll become real at some point — only without your participation, without your fingerprints. Then you might say someone stole your idea.

That’s nonsense. By default you threw it back.

An idea is intrinsically worthless until someone can catch it and has the gumption and the ability to develop it. To make it into reality. A whole bunch of folks may have conceived the idea of the incandescent light bulb, but it took an Edison to pull it off. More than a few tried to be the first to get a flying machine off the ground, to reach the South Pole, to design an operating system that would put computers into the hands of the masses. Several people might have had the idea to write the mother of all Mafia novels, but a relative unknown named Mario Puzo finally penned The Godfather — and triggered a whole franchise in the process, with sequels and everything.

But the funny thing is, if Edison or the Wright Brothers or Roald Amundsen or Mario Puzo didn’t do their work, it still would have been accomplished. Only Joe Smoe might have invented the light bulb, Joe Sixpack might have created the airplane, and Joe Lunchmeat might have written The Godfather.

Grab that idea. Assess it. If you can’t make it real, throw it back. Someone else will do something with it; applaud his success.

But if you can, pick it up. Run with it. Move it from the idea stage to the physical stage. Write that novel that’s bouncing around in your head. Compose that song you keep hearing. Invent that email reader that also checks your morning news, gives you your daily schedule and brews your morning coffee. Create that life-changing Android app. Develop that business plan and hang up your shingle.

Then you can claim it.


As I was getting ready to post, this article by Anne Wayman (About Freelance Writing) slipped across my transom. And yes, it shows how plentiful these ideas are. Check out her comments section to see how folks cope with the mental flood.

And while you’re about it, leave a comment here.